This Week's Golden Quisling Award: MSNBC Takes the Crown for Institutional Cowardice
The Golden Quisling goes to the organization that displays the most spectacular act of institutional cowardice each week. This week's winner distinguished itself not just through capitulation, but through the breathtaking speed and completeness of its surrender to pressure.
The Winner: MSNBC
In a week filled with corporate genuflection and institutional spine-removal, MSNBC has earned this week's Golden Quisling award for their handling of analyst Matthew Dowd's firing. What makes MSNBC's cowardice particularly egregious isn't just that they fired Dowd—it's the craven two-step dance they performed in doing so.
First, MSNBC President Rebecca Kutler issued a public apology, stating that Dowd's comments were "inappropriate, insensitive and unacceptable." But apparently, groveling wasn't enough. By the end of the same day, they had completely fired Dowd—a political analyst they had employed since 2022.
What did Dowd say that was so terrible? When asked about "the environment in which a shooting like this happens," he noted that Kirk had been "one of the most divisive younger figures" who was "constantly sort of pushing this sort of hate speech" and that "hateful thoughts lead to hateful words, which then lead to hateful actions." Whether you agree with that analysis or not, it's exactly the kind of political commentary news networks are supposed to provide.
Why MSNBC Stands Apart
What elevates MSNBC's cowardice above the pack is that they are supposed to be a news organization. Their entire business model depends on political analysis and commentary. Yet when faced with the slightest pushback, they didn't just apologize—they completely abandoned their own analyst and, by extension, the principle of journalistic independence.
As Dowd himself noted in his Substack response, "The Right Wing media mob ginned up, went after me on a plethora of platforms, and MSNBC reacted to that mob. Even though most at MSNBC knew my words were being misconstrued... I was terminated by the end of the day."
This wasn't a case of an employee going rogue or violating clear company policy. This was a political analyst doing exactly what political analysts are paid to do—analyze the political environment surrounding a news event. MSNBC's complete capitulation sends a chilling message: even news organizations will throw their own people under the bus at the first sign of organized pressure.
The Also-Rans: A Week of Corporate Cowardice
While MSNBC takes the crown, this week saw an impressive display of institutional spinelessness across multiple sectors:
The Airline Trifecta: American Airlines, Delta, and United Airlines all suspended or fired employees over social media posts within days, especially after Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy publicly pressured them. All three major carriers folded immediately when a government official made a few tweets.
Academic Institutions: Middle Tennessee State University fired assistant dean Laura Sosh-Lightsy "effective immediately" for her Facebook post, while public universities across the country demonstrated that academic freedom apparently has an expiration date measured in hours.
Federal Agencies: The U.S. Secret Service "immediately" suspended Anthony Pough for Facebook posts critical of Kirk, showing that even federal agencies will bypass due process when the pressure mounts.
Corporate America: From the Carolina Panthers firing a communications staffer within 24 hours to NextDoor terminating a Milwaukee employee, and even a Cincinnati barbecue restaurant co-owner getting the boot—the private sector showed remarkable unanimity in its lack of courage.
Retail Giants: Office Depot fired an employee in Michigan who allegedly refused to print Charlie Kirk memorial flyers, demonstrating that customer service now apparently requires political orthodoxy.
The Bigger Picture
Within 24 hours of Kirk's death, an assistant dean at a Tennessee college, a communications staffer for an NFL team, a NextDoor employee in Milwaukee, and the co-owner of a Cincinnati barbecue restaurant were all fired after posting about it. This wasn't organic outrage—this was an organized pressure campaign that succeeded because institutions chose the path of least resistance.
What makes this particularly disturbing is the speed. There were no investigations, no due process, no consideration of context or nuance. Just immediate termination at the first sign of controversy.
Why MSNBC Deserves the Golden Quisling
Among all these profiles in cowardice, MSNBC stands out because they had every reason to defend their analyst and every resource to weather the storm. Instead, they chose to legitimize the very "cancel culture" tactics they routinely criticize when used against conservatives.
News organizations are supposed to be different. They're supposed to understand that controversial commentary comes with the territory, that robust debate requires protecting unpopular viewpoints, and that journalistic independence means something. MSNBC's complete surrender on these principles makes them not just cowardly, but hypocritical.
By firing Dowd for doing exactly what they pay political analysts to do, MSNBC has signaled that they're willing to sacrifice their own credibility and their employees' livelihoods rather than face criticism. That's not journalism—that's performance art masquerading as news.
Congratulations, MSNBC. Your Golden Quisling award is well-earned.
The Golden Quisling award recognizes the week's most spectacular display of institutional cowardice. Previous winners include various corporations, educational institutions, and government agencies that chose capitulation over courage when faced with organized pressure campaigns.
This Week's Golden Quisling Award: MSNBC Takes the Crown for Institutional Cowardice
The Golden Quisling goes to the organization that displays the most spectacular act of institutional cowardice each week. This week's winner distinguished itself not just through capitulation, but through the breathtaking speed and completeness of its surrender to pressure.
The Winner: MSNBC
In a week filled with corporate genuflection and institutional spine-removal, MSNBC has earned this week's Golden Quisling award for their handling of analyst Matthew Dowd's firing. What makes MSNBC's cowardice particularly egregious isn't just that they fired Dowd—it's the craven two-step dance they performed in doing so.
First, MSNBC President Rebecca Kutler issued a public apology, stating that Dowd's comments were "inappropriate, insensitive and unacceptable." But apparently, groveling wasn't enough. By the end of the same day, they had completely fired Dowd—a political analyst they had employed since 2022.
What did Dowd say that was so terrible? When asked about "the environment in which a shooting like this happens," he noted that Kirk had been "one of the most divisive younger figures" who was "constantly sort of pushing this sort of hate speech" and that "hateful thoughts lead to hateful words, which then lead to hateful actions." Whether you agree with that analysis or not, it's exactly the kind of political commentary news networks are supposed to provide.
Why MSNBC Stands Apart
What elevates MSNBC's cowardice above the pack is that they are supposed to be a news organization. Their entire business model depends on political analysis and commentary. Yet when faced with the slightest pushback, they didn't just apologize—they completely abandoned their own analyst and, by extension, the principle of journalistic independence.
As Dowd himself noted in his Substack response, "The Right Wing media mob ginned up, went after me on a plethora of platforms, and MSNBC reacted to that mob. Even though most at MSNBC knew my words were being misconstrued... I was terminated by the end of the day."
This wasn't a case of an employee going rogue or violating clear company policy. This was a political analyst doing exactly what political analysts are paid to do—analyze the political environment surrounding a news event. MSNBC's complete capitulation sends a chilling message: even news organizations will throw their own people under the bus at the first sign of organized pressure.
The Also-Rans: A Week of Corporate Cowardice
While MSNBC takes the crown, this week saw an impressive display of institutional spinelessness across multiple sectors:
The Airline Trifecta: American Airlines, Delta, and United Airlines all suspended or fired employees over social media posts within days, especially after Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy publicly pressured them. All three major carriers folded immediately when a government official made a few tweets.
Academic Institutions: Middle Tennessee State University fired assistant dean Laura Sosh-Lightsy "effective immediately" for her Facebook post, while public universities across the country demonstrated that academic freedom apparently has an expiration date measured in hours.
Federal Agencies: The U.S. Secret Service "immediately" suspended Anthony Pough for Facebook posts critical of Kirk, showing that even federal agencies will bypass due process when the pressure mounts.
Corporate America: From the Carolina Panthers firing a communications staffer within 24 hours to NextDoor terminating a Milwaukee employee, and even a Cincinnati barbecue restaurant co-owner getting the boot—the private sector showed remarkable unanimity in its lack of courage.
Retail Giants: Office Depot fired an employee in Michigan who allegedly refused to print Charlie Kirk memorial flyers, demonstrating that customer service now apparently requires political orthodoxy.
The Bigger Picture
Within 24 hours of Kirk's death, an assistant dean at a Tennessee college, a communications staffer for an NFL team, a NextDoor employee in Milwaukee, and the co-owner of a Cincinnati barbecue restaurant were all fired after posting about it. This wasn't organic outrage—this was an organized pressure campaign that succeeded because institutions chose the path of least resistance.
What makes this particularly disturbing is the speed. There were no investigations, no due process, no consideration of context or nuance. Just immediate termination at the first sign of controversy.
Why MSNBC Deserves the Golden Quisling
Among all these profiles in cowardice, MSNBC stands out because they had every reason to defend their analyst and every resource to weather the storm. Instead, they chose to legitimize the very "cancel culture" tactics they routinely criticize when used against conservatives.
News organizations are supposed to be different. They're supposed to understand that controversial commentary comes with the territory, that robust debate requires protecting unpopular viewpoints, and that journalistic independence means something. MSNBC's complete surrender on these principles makes them not just cowardly, but hypocritical.
By firing Dowd for doing exactly what they pay political analysts to do, MSNBC has signaled that they're willing to sacrifice their own credibility and their employees' livelihoods rather than face criticism. That's not journalism—that's performance art masquerading as news.
Congratulations, MSNBC. Your Golden Quisling award is well-earned.
The Golden Quisling award recognizes the week's most spectacular display of institutional cowardice. Previous winners include various corporations, educational institutions, and government agencies that chose capitulation over courage when faced with organized pressure campaigns.
No comments:
Post a Comment