Wednesday, November 18, 2026

[A Necessary Abomination] Scoring Hakeem Jeffries Against His Own Promises: How the 73% Was Calculated - Does Hakeem Jeffery's word match his action? No. It does not.

 

Hakeem Jeffries scores 8 out of 11 points (73%) on the promises in his speech accepting the nomination for Speaker, measured against his record from November 2024 to November 18, 2026. The score covers two of his three promises. The third, lowering everyday costs, has no completed actions to score yet.

A percentage is only worth something if you can check it. This post lays out exactly which sources were used, how each one was marked, and how the points add up, so anyone can redo the count or argue with a specific call.

The promises being measured

The November 2026 speech, as quoted by Gemini, makes three commitments that can be checked against a record:

  1. Lower everyday costs: groceries, gas and housing, as part of "an affordable America."
  2. Health care for every American: making it affordable "for every single American."
  3. Hold the crooks accountable: for what he called corruption, chaos and cruelty.

One caveat up front: the quotes come from Gemini's account of the video. A verified transcript of the speech has not been found yet. If the actual wording differs, the promise list should be corrected before anything else.

The sources: what was examined

The source set is the footnoted reporting in Hakeem Jeffries's Wikipedia article, as it stood on November 18, 2026 (last edited 18:37 UTC). It is not every article published in two years. It is a fixed, public list that anyone can open and check.

  • Time window: November 18, 2024 to November 18, 2026. Items were dated by when the event happened, since many footnotes give only a "retrieved" date.
  • What counts as evidence: a vote, a bill, a petition, a formal letter, a protest action, or a public position he took. Each was read from Wikipedia's summary of the cited article.
  • What was left out: speeches and slogans with no action attached. His April 2025 "chaos, cruelty and corruption" speech, for example, isn't scored. A promise to fight is not evidence of fighting.
  • Two outside sources were added for the cost-of-living plans, because Wikipedia hadn't caught up on November 2026: E&E News and Spectrum News (linked below).

The scoring rules

Each item gets one mark against the promise it bears on:

Mark

Points

Meaning

For

1

The action moves toward the promise

Mixed

0.5

Part of the action moves toward it and part retreats, or the source title signals a step back without details

Against

0

The action cuts against the promise as he worded it

A promise's score is its points divided by its number of items. The overall score is total points over total items. A promise with no scorable actions gets no score, rather than a zero or a guess.

The health-care promise is read literally: "every single American" means universal coverage. That reading is why dropping Medicare for All counts as Against. Under a looser reading ("more affordable for most people") it would be Mixed, and the score would rise to 8.5 of 11 (77%).

Where the 73% comes from

Eleven items in the window bear on the health-care and accountability promises. Each row below gives what happened and how it was marked.

Promise

Date

What happened

Mark

Points

Health care

Feb 2025

"Dear Colleague" letter attacking GOP Medicaid cuts

For

1

Health care

Apr 2025

12-hour sit-in on the Capitol steps against the Medicaid cuts, with Sen. Cory Booker

For

1

Health care

Jul 2025

Record 8h44m floor speech against the One Big Beautiful Bill Act

For

1

Health care

Sep–Nov 2025

Made extending ACA tax credits the central demand of the 43-day shutdown

For

1

Health care

Nov 2025

Axios: House Democrats "back off another one of their red lines" on ending the shutdown

Mixed

0.5

Health care

Nov 2025–Jan 2026

Discharge petition for a 3-year ACA credit extension; passed the House 230–196

For

1

Health care

Aug 2026

Said he no longer supports Medicare for All, which he co-sponsored 2013–2021

Against

0

Accountability

Feb 2025

10-part plan, including a bill to block DOGE's "unlawful access" to Treasury payments

For

1

Accountability

Oct 2025

Fought the delayed swearing-in of Rep.-elect Grijalva, tied to the Epstein files vote

For

1

Accountability

Dec 2025

Backed Trump's pardon of Rep. Henry Cuellar on corruption charges

Against

0

Accountability

Nov 2026

Called for Defense Secretary Hegseth's removal but stopped short of impeachment

Mixed

0.5

The math:

  • Health care: 5.5 points of 7 = 79%
  • Accountability: 2.5 points of 4 = 63%
  • Overall: 8 points of 11 = 73%

What wasn't scored, and why

Lowering grocery, gas and housing costs. Democrats held the House minority for the whole window, so the record holds plans, not completed actions. Scoring plans would credit him for promises, which is the thing being tested. His stated plans so far:

  • A "Dear Colleague" letter set up five working groups to draft affordability bills: housing, gas and utilities, groceries and goods, caregiving, and health care (E&E News).
  • At a November 12, 2026 news conference he backed raising the minimum wage, banning congressional stock trading and moving toward universal health care (Spectrum News).
  • He said the Iran war has driven up gas and food prices and urged war-powers votes to end it (NPR, November 6, 2026).

This promise gets scored once the new Congress is seated on January 3, 2027.

Israel. Israel policy isn't one of the promises in this speech, so it isn't in the score. It is tracked separately. In the window he met Prime Minister Netanyahu (April 2025) and accepted J Street's endorsement for the first time (August 2025). He also opposed Rep. Massie's amendment to cut $3.3 billion in military aid to Israel and voted against it, but let members vote their conscience (July 2026).

Limits, and how to check the work

  • Selection. Wikipedia editors chose these sources. An editor who favors or opposes Jeffries could tilt which events appear. A larger set of articles would test whether 73% holds.
  • Depth. Each item was marked from Wikipedia's one- or two-sentence summary, not the full article. One item (the Axios "red lines" story) was marked from its headline alone, which is why it is Mixed.
  • Small sample. With 11 items, one changed mark moves the overall score by 4 to 9 points.
  • Unverified claims left out. An earlier AI summary said Jeffries had "just this week" backed lowering the Medicare age to 55. A search found no support, so it isn't scored.

To extend this, add rows to the table using the same three marks and the same rule: actions count, speeches don't. Every row should link to its source so readers can check the call.

Sources